Why You Keep Doubting Yourself
Perhaps you worry about whether you're good enough at your job, whether you've made the right decision, or what other people think of you. You might spend time going over it again and again in your head, looking for reassurance from someone else, or trying to convince yourself that everything is fine.
And sometimes, you succeed. You find an answer, feel reassured, and can move on. But before long, there's something else to doubt.
But what if the problem isn't actually the thing you're doubting, but the doubting itself?
Why solving one doubt at a time doesn't help
We tend to treat doubt as though it's about something specific. If we're worried about our appearance, we focus on changing how we look. If we're worried about our abilities, we look for reassurance that we're capable. If we're questioning a decision we've made, we think about it until we're satisfied.
The difficulty is that, for some people, resolving one concern doesn't stop the doubts. They simply move on to something else. It's like a conveyor belt. One worry is dealt with, and then the next arrives.
And sometimes, the more we try to resolve each doubt, the more we strengthen the habit of doubting. We might feel better temporarily, but we become more accustomed to questioning ourselves and searching for reassurance whenever another concern appears.
This is why self-doubt can be so exhausting, and why it often goes hand in hand with a noisy mind. You can spend enormous amounts of time trying to answer individual questions without ever feeling more secure in yourself.
Let's look at self-doubt differently
In Process-Based Behaviour Therapy (PBBT), we look at self-doubt from a different perspective. Rather than focusing entirely on what you're doubting, we're interested in the behaviour of doubting.
Doubting is something we do, and like other behaviours, there's a reason we do it. Understanding that reason can help us recognise what's really going on. Very often, the things we're questioning on the surface are connected to something much more personal underneath.
For example, imagine someone who, as they get older, becomes increasingly concerned about how they look. They begin noticing changes in their face and body. They spend more time looking in the mirror, comparing themselves with others or thinking about ways to look younger.
They might change their hairstyle, buy new clothes or try different treatments, hoping these changes will help them feel better. And perhaps they do, for a little while. But the doubts keep returning.
What if the deeper concern was never really about appearance? What if the questions underneath were: "Am I still loved? Am I still attractive to my partner? Do I still have something valuable to offer?"
Changing how you look may do very little to answer those questions. And that's the important distinction. Sometimes we spend our energy trying to solve the thing we're doubting, rather than understanding why we're doubting ourselves in the first place.
So, what can you do when you notice yourself doing this?
A useful first step is to ask yourself what might be underneath it. Here are some questions to think about:
- Am I questioning whether I'm good enough or capable?
- Am I questioning whether I matter or have something worthwhile to contribute?
- Am I worried about being loved, wanted or accepted?
- Am I questioning whether I can trust or rely on the people around me?
- Am I worried about how others see me?
Take a moment to look at these questions. You might find that one stands out to you more than the others.
The next step is to ask yourself whether there's something genuine that needs your attention. Sometimes there is. Perhaps you really would benefit from addressing a difficulty or making a change in your life. If that’s the case, then that's worth attending to, so take whatever practical steps are needed to make that change.
Going back to our earlier example, if the underlying concern is about feeling loved or valued, perhaps what's needed isn't another change in appearance, but an honest conversation with your partner about how you're feeling, or giving more attention to the relationships that really matter to you.
But if there's no clear problem to solve, repeatedly questioning yourself will simply keep the cycle of doubt going. So, instead of trying to answer the same question again and again, gently redirect your attention towards something that genuinely needs your time and energy. When the doubt returns, remind yourself what actually needs your attention, rather than starting the whole process of questioning again.
The aim isn't to dismiss your concerns or force yourself to stop thinking. It's to recognise which concerns need action and which ones are keeping you caught in the process of doubting.
Sometimes it's difficult to see what's really going on
When you're caught up in self-doubt, it can be surprisingly difficult to recognise what's underneath it. You may feel completely convinced that the problem is your appearance, your ability or a particular decision you've made. Sometimes, simply sharing these concerns with someone you trust can help you see them differently.
Talking something through takes it outside your own head and gives you an opportunity to consider a perspective that can be difficult to access when you're caught in the middle of it.
If you've tried these suggestions but still find it difficult to understand what's really behind your self-doubt, that's okay. Sometimes, even with the support of someone close to you, it can be hard to work through these things on your own.
Therapy can offer another way to explore what's going on and help you make sense of it. At the PBBT Clinic, we can support you in understanding where your self-doubt comes from and finding new ways to respond to it. If you'd like to explore whether therapy might be helpful for you, please feel free to book a free, no-obligation, online consultation here.