The Gap between Therapy Training and Clinical Practice
When I was studying Statistics as an undergraduate in Psychology, I wondered how it would ever be relevant to understanding and helping people. It never was. And even though I taught on an undergraduate Psychology degree for many years, it has never been clear to me why courses are so full of irrelevancies and so devoid of the practical skills needed to really help people.
The elephant in the room is the enormous gap between what we learn during our early professional training and what we actually need to know to help people.
The Problem Keeps Going
Ironically, the inadequacies of undergraduate training have not led to a proliferation of postgraduate courses packed with what young helping professionals really need to learn.
On the contrary, many simply repackage undergraduate material, keeping the early professional knowledge base just as stunted. This has led to a situation where psychology students almost everywhere have to keep jumping qualification hurdles before finally accessing good training where they will learn what they need.
All of the time prior to this is essentially wasted, both for the professionals and for those who really need our help.
Protocol Adherence Is Not Clinical Competence
Perhaps this situation, in part, explains why the field of psychotherapy shifted so significantly towards protocol adherence, a natural assumption being that Practitioners didn't really know what they were doing.
And how could they, in spite of years of 'training'?
As adherence became the standard, it was slowly equated with clinical competence. And that's where a key problem lies.
Adherence is adherence. It cannot, by itself, establish clinical competence. Clinical work demands much more than following prescribed steps because it is organically embedded in directed human interactions and unpredictable dialogue.
The Problem with Diagnosis-Driven Therapy
In a field where the working manual, the DSM, gives rise to an inordinate number of labels, with an expectation that we match different treatments to different labels, it is again no wonder that we became so focused on adherence.
Practitioners are juggling a dozen models and doing their best to match these with Clients who fit more than one label and don't fit any particularly well.
Using clinical time in this way is not what any of us signed up for, nor is it what Clients signed up for either.
Not the Way to Learn to Drive
Imagine if every driving lesson was a variation of the driving theory test, and the Instructor explained in detail how road signs were created, how they can be interpreted, and so on.
You'd really understand road signs, but your driving wouldn't be great.
Driving theory is very different from the mechanics of driving. It's about interpreting the road signs that guide driving, but it is not the same as learning to drive itself.
The majority of psychology training focuses on detecting and interpreting road signs, but very little teaches you to drive.
Training Needs to Be Competency-Based
The field's move towards competency is undoubtedly a positive sign. But there is also a debate to be had about what we mean by competencies.
Do those competencies include a genuine understanding of the human suffering we see every day in our clinics?
Are we training Practitioners to develop that understanding so that, over time, they really know what is making the human being in front of them suffer?
And do those competencies include genuine skills in changing that suffering in a targeted and precise way that fits the individual?
Are we training Practitioners to really know how to change what people do in a lasting way?
If these are not the foundations of our trained competencies, then perhaps we are still just training adherence.
What Clinical Competencies Look Like
As a highly precise, entirely scientifically-based therapeutic regime, the language of PBBT is the language of competencies.
Competencies to understand the key processes that make complex humans complex and human.
Competencies to understand how these processes lead to variations, and how those variations are highly predictable and inevitable based on lived experiences.
And competencies to harness those lived experiences to create transformation.
Competencies to facilitate where Clients want to take their lives, rather than simply giving them tricks and tips to manage what history has done to them.
Good psychotherapy training should not be afraid to talk about its competencies.
All psychotherapy training providers owe this to the professionals they train, and ultimately, to the Clients those professionals are there to help.
Want to learn more?
Join us for an introductory webinar on Process-Based Behaviour Therapy (PBBT).